Skip to content

“Early Decision” Shines a Light on College Admission

September 18, 2013

The all-important date of October 1 is drawing near. What’s so critical about October 1, you ask? The date has little significance for most people in the world. But for those familiar with college admissions – including high school seniors – October 1 is the day that most universities start accepting applications for admission.

Lacy Crawford, author of Early Decision, is all-too familiar with this deadline. Lacy is considered an “application whisperer” to upper-class households with elite kids applying to colleges. Her novel, which is “based on a true frenzy,” follows five high school seniors from August of their senior year until they hit “SUBMIT” on the college applications. All five students are working on their applications with the help of Anne, an independent college counselor whose phone number is a rich parent’s best-kept secret. The book is a fictionalized account of Lacy’s experiences.

early decisionThe students in the book – as well as all the actual students applying to college – spend an enormous amount of time and mental energy writing the perfect college admission essay in hopes of the coveted offer of admission to their schools of choice. It is both heartbreaking and jaw-dropping to read about these students, their college admission essays and the lengths to which their parents will go to make sure they are admitted into the “best” school possible.

One of the reasons I found this book so intriguing is because of my own experience with college applications. For several years when I was at San Diego State University (SDSU), I oversaw communications for the SDSU Office of the Admissions. While I was not the person in charge of making admission decisions (thank goodness for that!), I was involved extensively in the communications process and I personally penned several of the “Congratulations, you’ve been accepted” letters, along with the “Sorry, you were not selected” variety.

Unlike the colleges that the students in Lacy’s novel were applying to, San Diego State is a large public university that does not require a personal essay for admission. Decisions were based strictly off a formula that took into account the high school Grade Point Average and an SAT /ACT test score. But even with a cut-and-dry formula, it was still heartbreaking to see how few students were accepted and how devastated many were when they were notified they were not going to SDSU.

So many people think that admission to a public university is an easy thing. But when that university relies on California state funding to determine the number of students it can admit, there were times when only 6,500 seats were open to more than 65,000 applicants. That’s an awful lot of students who were not  admitted. In that respect, I certainly related to the desperation felt by the parents in Early Decision when it came to getting their son or daughter into college.

Early Decision is a fascinating look at the college application process from the point of view of the parents and students. Lacy makes great points in the book, including how students are not taught to explore their interests (by parents and high school); how ill-prepared a kid is to write a personal essay; and how so many public high schools are not able to navigate admission to top universities. The book is also entertaining and relatable to any parent who wants the best for their child and to see them achieve success.

Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of Early Decision to review for this blog post.  All opinions are my own and I only endorse books that I am proud to recommend to others.

Other Posts You May Like:

8 Comments leave one →
  1. September 18, 2013 3:37 am

    We just saw the movie Admission with Tiny Fey.
    An amusing look into the process. Having gone through it with 3 kids, and helping a couple of seniors now with their essays, I know the stress involved.

  2. Shary permalink
    September 18, 2013 4:54 am

    Sounds like a gripping novel and also a must read for parents of college bound kids. Sharing this one!

  3. September 18, 2013 6:01 am

    Sounds like a very interesting book. I look forward to checking it out. Working at a university, I also can relate. And it also brings up the unfortunate differences in socioeconomic classes when applying to college. Most families can’t afford their own personal college application counselor (not that there is anything wrong with using one for those who can). And as you say, high school counselors are rarely able to give the attention necessary to every senior. It’s a fascinating process with a lot of room for improvement on both the student and college side!

  4. September 19, 2013 11:14 am

    I never really thought about the limited number of seats at state schools (and how competitive it is – especially now – with no job market opportunities). For more than 15 years, I’ve worked primarily in (and – “with” – as a freelancers) private higher education. So while the essays were familiar to me, the competition at state universities wasn’t so obvious. The books sounds fabulous.

  5. September 20, 2013 7:33 am

    When I went to college I applied to only one school – a state school. I got a partial scholarship. I worked and earned about $300 per month to cover my rent and other expenses. It’s such a different world now. For a couple of decades I taught in schools filled with students who had jumped through all these hoops. One of the most touching essays written in one of my composition classes was from a student who was #1 in his class and clearly on a trajectory to success in life. However, in his essay he lamented that he never had the chance to take any classes just for fun, like art. I hope as he’s moved on through his adult life he’s slowed down and started to explore himself a little more.

  6. September 23, 2013 12:42 pm

    I’ve had this book on my TBR list for a while, and now I want to read it even more. Both my kids have been through the process (and college) but it fascinates me. Truth be told, I’ve also thought it would be interesting to be an admissions officer. I read “The Gate Keepers” (about admission into Wesleyan), and I loved that. I guess maybe I enjoy the behind the scenes aspect.


  1. Meet the Jenn Crowell of "Etched On Me" (And Win a Book) | Leah's Thoughts
  2. Erika Robuck's New Novel Shines Light on Poet Edna St. Vincent Millay (Giveaway) | Leah's Thoughts

Leave a Reply to Caryn Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: